With all the Star Wars Talk going on as of late I am seeing a resurgence of the bashing that follows the prequel trilogy, and for the record – yes they were bad, yes that had flaws, and yes they cursed us with the knowledge that Jar-Jar Binks is now part of our Star Wars collective consciousness – BUT IT IS STILL STAR WARS!!! I think the beating they have gotten if far worse than they deserve.
Episode I: The Phantom Menace
Production Budget: $115,000,000.
Domestic Total Gross: $431,088,295
Domestic Lifetime Gross: $474,544,677
Flaws: An awful introduction of Anakin Skywalker, An attempt to explain The Force using “science” (Midichlorians), FUCKING JAR-JAR BINKS, Underuse of Darth Maul, terrible dialog, and too much focus on the special effects juggernaut that was the pod races.
Strengths: Liam Neeson as Quai Gon Jin, Ewan McGregor as a fucking fantastic young Obi Wan Kenobi, Natalie Portman as Padme Amidala, and some of the BEST saber fights that have ever been brought to the big screen.
The first episode of the prequel had some great actors setting the story for what would be the tone of the trilogy. We were introduced to the Jedi in a way we had yet to see before – in their prime. We saw the trickery of the Sith before they were in power. We saw the worlds as they were meant to be seen in the mind’s eye come to life in vivid colors and masterful imagery. I think the portrayal of the Star Wars universe was damned near perfect. And it all falls apart with the introduction of - Anakin Skywalker.
In my opinion they tried entirely too hard to show the audience how special he was (The virgin birth really puts it over the top). While I don’t think the midichlorians are a result of Anakin’s story it becomes all the more offensive by association. What makes it worse is I believe that the casting of Jake Lloyd was perfect based on the look of the character. Jake Lloyd LOOKED like he had some anger Management issues – but they never gave him dialog or scenes in which he could show that anger. The failure in this respect was not the poor performance we saw, it is the poor writing the character was given.
When I envision a young Darth Vader (of course assuming I know he turns out to be the evil ruler of the galaxy), I envision a character more along the lines of the one played by Pierce Gagnon (Cid) in the movie Looper (which has its own set of problems, but I am not here to talk about that now). That little boy was disturbed and angry and he acted out. You could SEE the potential for evil in his character. Young Anakin Skywalker was simply too good and too fanciful a character and did not fit into the Mythos of Darth Vader. They gave him a story line in which he gets to save the day – TWICE. It appears to me that they tried to force him into the role of Luke Skywalker, which was completely unnecessary.
What Would I do differently?
First of all I would have completely changed the story of Anakin’s background. I would have made his father an unknown, but hinted that he could have been a Jedi. I would have made the character less well adapted to his situation as a slave. And I would have killed his mother off in the first movie and have him see it happen. How they killed her off was fine, but it should have happened at a younger age to plant the seeds of anger and hatred.
I also would have focused more on the relationship between Qui Gon and Obi Wan. I would have written their relationship a little more abrasive than it was and Kenobi as far less submissive. The death of Qui Gon and the subsequent battle with Darth Maul should have been a flirtation with the Dark Side that Obi Wan overcomes, akin to the moment where Luke gives into his anger to defeat Vader in Episode VI. Kenobi should have had more flaws – a trait that made Qui Gon such an interesting character as a Jedi. This movie had all the right elements to give it the potential to be a great Star Wars film. Its failure is in the delivery.
In my next installment I'll tackle Episode II: Attack of the The Clones. Stay Tuned!
1. Robocop **
2. The Lego Movie**
4. Captain America: Winter Soldier *****
5. Veronica Mars ***
6. The Amazing Spider-Man 2 ***
7. X-Men: Days of Future Past *****
9. Maleficent ****
10. The Fault In Our Stars *****
11. Edge of Tomorrow ****
12. How To Train Your Dragon 2 *****
13. Transformers: Age Of Extinction *
14. Dawn of The Planet of The Apes *****
15. Lucy ***
16. Guardians Of The Galaxy *****
17. Dracula Untold ***
18. The Judge ****
I'm not real big on begging, but keeping this running and trying to get better costs money. If you like what we do or if you are just feeling altruistic - toss us a buck? Every little bit helps and you'd get a great big thank you from us! And we may even dedicate something silly to you for your support!
HomeArticlesStar Wars: Episodes I, II, and III – Am I really the only person who does not absolutely hate them?
Slider is the Host and founder of The M Cluster, formerly a weekly You Tube show that focuses on discussing movies, but extends to all corners of general geekdom. (I say formerly because I have found a need to fallback and re-group - which has proven to be not the easiest of tasks.)He is a bit of an enigma, even to himself. He considers himself a renaissance man of sorts, having dabbled in writing, acting, singing and having work experiences ranging from delivering pizzas to working on worldwide information systems for Fortune 500 companies to digging for soil samples on a remote island off the coast of Africa. He has traveled most of the world, but would like to see the rest of it.In his words "The art of storytelling has always been something that has fascinated me. More than anyone I know, I was truly raised by television and the movies. So doing this show is my attempt at being part of that world with which I feel so familiar."
I'm not real big on begging, but keeping this running and trying to get better costs money. If you like what we do or if you are just feeling altruistic - toss us a buck? Every little bit helps and you'd get a great big thank you from us! And we may even dedicate something silly to you for your support! (We even take requests!)