The success of the MCU can be attributed (in my opinion) to a couple of major factors:
Taking the characters seriously
Putting together a team that knows and cares for the source material
Allowing the team to write for both the die hard fans and casual fans alike
THEY TOOK THEIR TIME!
The Avengers did not bring in $1.5 billion dollars because they threw a bunch of heroes on the screen together as fast as they could. It took four years and six films to get that kind of Mojo composed. Batman v Superman intends to ram multiple major characters from the DC universe down our throats all at once. I can't help but see this image in my head:
In the MCU, we were introduced to each character and went along on their journeys with them. We got to know them as individuals. We got to explore their individual triumphs and failures. We got to experience their sacrifices and pain. We the audience let them woo us - and we didn't let them go all they way until the 6th date! And we were not disappointed, because we keep coming back for more.
Proof that we as an audience wanted more came with the first movie in Phase 2 - Iron Man 3. This was the first of the Standalone Marvel hero movies to break the billion dollar barrier, bringing in an impressive $1.2 billion all on it's own. This led the way to not only the core heroes we've already seen having flourishing franchises, but to the development of new franchises in Ant Man and The Guardians of The Galaxy, not to mention bringing Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. to life and a group of new projects in conjunction with Netflix.
Investing the time in the franchise and the characters can only bring about good things for D.C., If they would only stop trying to re-invent the wheel.
How Can the Creative Team Behind Batman v Superman Avoid Disaster?
I think the answer to this is relatively simple, STOP DIGGING A HOLE - dial it back. You've already announced the characters, now smartly put them to use. The story:
Needs to be about Superman and Batman (Yes I think giving Batman top billing in the Man Of Steel sequel is idiotic). Give them some tension, I think the best Superman/Batman moments are because of that tension - it is OK for them to not exactly like each other.
Should use Luthor as the mechanism to pit them against each other and have them overcome that manipulation to see through the farce. Give them each their moments and turn it around in the end to stop the true villain.
Should NOTuse Diana as a main character. (I know this is a rough one, but hear me out.) Bring her in towards the end of the film, her attention drawn to the world outside of Themyscira by the events of Man of Steel and the current conflict. Her intention is to help, and use that meeting to lay the foundation for the Justice League. Save her for the Justice League Movie and a Standalone franchise.
Should NOT, for the love of all things nerdy - make Batman the grandpa of the future Justice League.
I get it, you want him to be old and seasoned a la Frank Miller, but I think it is time to take a page from Nolan's Batman franchise here. Without exactly leaning on his Batman universe, pick up where The Dark Knight Rises left off. He's been out of the game for a while, he's battered, tired, but well seasoned. You can have a more experienced Batman without making him 60 years old. A late 30's to early 40's character would serve this purpose just fine AND leave room for the Frank Miller confrontation story should they wish to do it later on.
To DC and Warner Brothers, my plea to you is this - take your time and flesh this new universe out. These fans are not going anywhere. Respect the mythology from which these characters come and protect their continuity. You have the opportunity to make some of the greatest Super Hero movies of all time if only you would take your time. Don't give us the DC Cinematic Universe you think we need right now - give us, your audience, your fans the DC Cinematic Universe we deserve.
Go to the next page and vote in our Poll... let us know what YOU think should happen and share your opinion in the comments below!
Image Credit: TokoWallpapers
1. Robocop **
2. The Lego Movie**
4. Captain America: Winter Soldier *****
5. Veronica Mars ***
6. The Amazing Spider-Man 2 ***
7. X-Men: Days of Future Past *****
9. Maleficent ****
10. The Fault In Our Stars *****
11. Edge of Tomorrow ****
12. How To Train Your Dragon 2 *****
13. Transformers: Age Of Extinction *
14. Dawn of The Planet of The Apes *****
15. Lucy ***
16. Guardians Of The Galaxy *****
17. Dracula Untold ***
18. The Judge ****
I'm not real big on begging, but keeping this running and trying to get better costs money. If you like what we do or if you are just feeling altruistic - toss us a buck? Every little bit helps and you'd get a great big thank you from us! And we may even dedicate something silly to you for your support!
HomeMovie NewsIs Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice on a Heading for Franchise Disaster?
I'm not real big on begging, but keeping this running and trying to get better costs money. If you like what we do or if you are just feeling altruistic - toss us a buck? Every little bit helps and you'd get a great big thank you from us! And we may even dedicate something silly to you for your support! (We even take requests!)